CFTC Bypassed Legal Requirement in Trying to Serve Ooki DAO, Crypto Supporters Claim – Yahoo Finance





The Commodity Futures Trading Commission is trying to “create [a] novel precedent” for itself in trying to serve a lawsuit to the entirety of a decentralized autonomous organization, rather than to the DAO’s members, one of three filings pushing back against the agency’s lawsuit said.
The filings, published Monday, are responses to the CFTC’s earlier pushback against the amicus briefs filed by crypto legal consortium LeXpunK, venture-capital firms Andreessen Horowitz and Paradigm and the DeFi Education Fund.
The CFTC sued Ooki DAO in September, alleging the organization illegally offered crypto derivatives products to U.S. customers. The CFTC made similar allegations against bZeroX, a company that acted as a predecessor to Ooki.
The four original briefs argued that the CFTC’s method of serving notice on Ooki DAO’s members – which was done by posting a notice in a DAO-run forum and via a chatbot on the DAO’s website – was unlawful, and DAO members affected by the lawsuit should have been notified directly.
Because of the unorthodox nature of the notice, the CFTC had to ask the California judge overseeing the case to approve its methods. The briefs say the judge should reconsider.
The CFTC pushed back in its own filing last week, claiming that because the DAO was clearly aware of the lawsuit (its members discussed it in the DAO forum and on the DAO’s official Twitter account posted about it), notice had been properly served.
But the new briefs now say that isn't enough.
Andreessen Horowitz said in its brief Monday that the CFTC didn't describe any efforts it had made to identify members of the DAO. Under California state law, the regulator would have to try to identify individuals to serve, the filing said.
Much of the filing focuses on that argument, detailing why the venture fund believes the CFTC has failed to meet legal requirements for serving Ooki.
The arguments made by Andreesen Horowitz’s lawyers echo those of the DeFi Education Fund, which attempt to convince the court that the CFTC didn't properly serve notice and that allowing the federal regulator to skirt existing legal requirements just because the technology involved in the case is novel could risk the Constitutional right to due process.
LeXpunK alleges that the CFTC hasn't even proven that Ooki is an “unincorporated association” under the law.
“The CFTC relies upon a razor-thin metaphysical distinction between the Ooki DAO and Ooki Protocol. According to the CFTC, the Ooki Protocol is software. In contrast, (per the CFTC) the Ooki DAO is ‘a group of users of the Ooki Protocol who (a) chose not to incorporate, and (b) both held and actually voted governance tokens to participate in the business of running the Ooki Protocol pursuant to specific, publicized governance protocols.’ The CFTC claims that it ‘is not a novel proposition’ that individuals who use the same software can be deemed members of an unincorporated association by virtue of that software use. Not only is this a novel proposition, it is unprecedented. It would likely surprise Microsoft Word users to learn that editing the same document as another person is enough to form an unincorporated association,” LeXpunK said.
Paradigm didn't file a response to the CFTC’s motion by the Monday deadline.
A hearing to discuss the CFTC’s motion for alternative service is slated for Dec. 7.
As questions swirl about how much cryptocurrencies will be worth in the wake of the spectacular collapse of the crypto exchange FTX and other major platforms,
Take-Two Interactive is into Web3, but its Rockstar Games studio just put a stop to NFT use in modded Grand Theft Auto V servers.
The Web3 industry has just witnessed the worst event in its decade-long history – the FTX collapse, devastating the confidence of our industry in and out. This is not the first time something like …
The FTX is a wake-up call for everyone in the industry. And, no, regulation isn't going to save us next time, any more than it would have this time.
The policy, provided by insurance marketplace Lloyd’s of London, will support institutional investors’ NFTs up to $25 million.
Simeon High School basketball star Ben Wilson was gunned down on Vincennes Avenue on Nov. 21, 1984. In the days afterward, many were asking where such violence started and how it can be stopped. CBS 2's John Davis reports.
This boom was dominated by non-fungible tokens (NFT), and during this time a distinct narrative emerged around Web3 gaming. Predicated on early successes such as CryptoKitties, Web3 gaming became the Holy Grail that would finally bring together the scarcity of NFTs, the incentivization of cryptocurrencies and the utility of the metaverse. The gaming industry wasn’t taken over, and we have no shining examples of Web3 gaming live in today’s market.
(Bloomberg) — Most Read from BloombergMalaysia Latest: Muhyiddin Turns Down King on Unity GovernmentHow Bad Will Housing Get? The Chill Gripping a Once-Hot Market Offers a TestElon Musk's 2022 Wealth Loss Exceeds $100 Billion for First TimeFTX Latest: Key Takeaways From Tuesday’s Bankruptcy HearingBeyond Meat Plant’s Dirty Conditions Revealed in Photos, DocumentsBinance Chief Executive Officer Changpeng “CZ” Zhao and several deputies met with investors in Abu Dhabi last week in an effort to rai
Argentina's fan token, on the other hand, slid 21% following the team's loss on Monday.
Wall Street tends to co-opt new ideas in finance. That's how we got to FTX and a black eye for cryptos.
In today's rather welcome bullish rally across most risk assets, Coinbase (NASDAQ: COIN) is among the top stocks in focus. This move appears to be a bounce back rally, following a rather dismal performance yesterday. Coinbase shares hit their lowest level on record, with the regulated centralized crypto exchange seeing its market capitalization briefly dip below the $10 billion range.
Managers asked to categorise six per cent of Alphabet’s workforce as poor performers
Bell today announced a three-year strategic relationship with Montréal innovation centre, Centech. As Centech's exclusive telecommunications provider, Bell will leverage its advanced network capabilities, 5G and AI management expertise to help emerging Canadian businesses drive innovation, growth and adoption of advanced technological solutions.
Privacy coins like Monero and Zcash could soon be playing a much larger role in the multibillion-dollar world of cybercrime crypto transfers.
Decentralization was, and still is, the answer, says the co-founder of NEAR Protocol.
"Are you bitcoin rich these days? And, I think I read that you are working doing IT for a company there in Russia. Is that the case? And why do you need to work?”
These three cryptos are among the biggest decliners in a market that can't seem to find its footing.
The sports-betting service said it believed some customers' login information was compromised on other sites and used to access their DraftKings accounts.
Since its creation in July 2015, Ethereum's (CRYPTO: ETH) price has skyrocketed more than 44,000%, making it one of the best financial assets to have owned over that time frame. With a market cap as of this writing of $154 billion, Ethereum is worth more than major corporations like Netflix, PayPal, and Starbucks. Ethereum is the world's largest blockchain that has smart-contract functionality.
The legal right to control the item may or may not be intrinsically part of the NFT. Copyright law introduces additional complexity: Transferring ownership does not inherently transfer copyright. U.S. copyright law has stringent requirements for transferring copyright, which are not guaranteed to be met by smart contracts.

source



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.